RSS Feed

JSON, XML and the Meaning of Life

September 5, 2018

And it came about that the computer was born and all was good. Then there was another computer and the need to share things. It was easy. Knowing both sides, we can send data the computer understands. But wait, now some computers see the binary world differently. OK, let's make it human readable. Computers are faster at deserialisation by then. Comma separated variable (CSV) files became popular, but they lacked depth. Enter SGML and then XML. Fifty years have passed. There are signs at the airport saying "We are an XML Company!". What does that mean? It's just a way for all machines (and some people) to be able to read the same data. XML uses a DTD (document type definition). If an XML document does not pass the DTD rules, then it is no good. Toss it out. Great for developers. If it passes the rules, then it is easy to deserialise directly into a computer readable (i.e. binary format) object. Mind you, by hiding the structure from the developers they were free to build as they liked. I have seen Windows applications where to change the state in a drop-down will cause millions of bytes to pass between client and server. And everyone was happy. Then JavaScript became more standardised and faster, and the Web App was born. Parsing XML in JavaScript was slow and difficult - even without checking it against a DTD. Unlike traditional server languages, JavaScript has dynamic data structures. You can send any structured data down the line and only work out what it contains when you need to. Some bright spark decided to send JavaScript source full of data structures. Javascript is fast at compiling itself. This method is now called JSONP. But, sending code has its risks even in a sandbox. Besides we can make the JavaScript compiler even faster if we give it a more rigid format and a subset of JavaScript. JSON was born. And all was good. Then the people who don't live flexibility said "We can't have that" and started insisting on rigid structures in JavaScript. So, now we have something like XML but without the DTD to help us get it right at both ends. Developers are now spending more time than with XML.


We must stand up and fight. JSON for JSON. Allow me to get the data I need, not just what the suites have defined.

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Please reload

Featured Posts

My limited tests show that Dictionary is faster than `SortedList`. The latter uses `Array.BinarySearch` to find entries. I have read other performance...

How are C# Dictionaries so Fast?

August 27, 2018

Please reload

Recent Posts

April 12, 2018

Please reload

Please reload

Search By Tags
Please reload

Follow Us
  • Facebook Basic Square
  • Twitter Basic Square
  • Google+ Basic Square